| VI | EN | RU | ID | Settings |
TIL that despite being blamed for the French Revolution, King Louis XVI actually tried to overhaul France's broken tax system by abolishing noble tax exemptions and passing a universal land tax—only to have his reforms repeatedly blocked by the aristocracy and courts.
r/todayilearned · u/PageVanDamme · 4.8K pts · 139 comments
139 comments
Immediate_Gain_9480 · 81 pts
Its why initially the revolution was against the artistocracy. The revolutionaries were happy to maintain the king as constitutional monarch. The first French constitution if 1789 was signed into law by the king and kept him as head of state.
This only changed when the king tried to flee. At that point he and the royal family were seen as trying to reverse the revolution. Which they were.
So populair opinion turned against him. Which ended on the guilotine. Even that was very controversial and only decided by a single vote..
ProfessionalOil2014 · 49 pts
The same thing happened in Republican Rome.
The fall of the republic could have been prevented at literally any time, but private money lenders, rich patricians, and corrupt senators literally murdered people who attempted to resolve the issues with land, debt, and agriculture.
PageVanDamme · 24 pts
Interesting, I keep hearing it was "Degeneracy" and "cultural degradation" \*Sarcasm\*
Dillweed999 · 13 pts
If the most powerful people in society murdered anyone who tried to do reforms maybe the fall of the republic couldn't have been prevented at any time
Necessary-Reading605 · 7 pts
Good thing that will never happen in our lifetimes!
LorekeeperZinnia2014 · 3 pts
Did Augustus do anything about the aristocrats in the way, or did he reward them under his new monarchical autocracy?
vi0l3t-crumbl3 · 2 pts
Hmm... Wonder if history has any lessons for us...
TheElf27 · 0 pts
The republic was doomed by the time of ceasar and pompey. It should have arguably fallen even sooner. It was filled with corruption to a level that we couldn’t comprehend even if we tried.
Sonchay · 29 pts
Revolutions tend to do well against rulers who are indecisive or lack political instincts. Louis XVI I find puts me in mind of Tsar Nicholas II. In both cases the revolution took place over a somewhat staged or gradual basis, where first there were calls for reform or constitutional monarchy, alongside which the ruler just continued again and again to slightly misjudge or mistime their decisions - getting things wrong in a way which perpetuated the revolution until the point that it was clear they were going to be removed entirely. A more decisive ruler may have prevented their other throw or
3232330 · 17 pts
Physiocratic Economics argued for the universal land tax or Impôt unique. This lead to Henry George's theory known as the Land Value Tax.
Perseus_NL · 14 pts
Well yes, that's essentially what got the French Revolution going?
The French treasury needed more cash, the government tried reforming the tax laws, the wealthy nobility then demanded that the Estates gather for the first time in 200-some years to 'approve' the changes (block them of course), then came demands that the people got more representation in the Estates than the landed nobility and the church aaaand they were off to the races.
Poglosaurus · 13 pts
It's difficult to know just how much Louis himself was in favor of reform, he mostly did what the last person he talked to told him to do. His ministers saw that the reforms was necessary but he never made the effort that would have been needed to start a change because he also listened to his wife and friends.
Same pattern in the end when he publicly took the role of head of a parliamentary monarchy but allowed plot to put an end to the revolution with foreign monarchs help to continue. He was very indecisive and cowardly.
Shevek99 · 13 pts
"The most perilous moment for a bad government is one when it seeks to mend its ways."
Alexis de Tocqueville, The Old Regime and the French Revolution
The_Rotating_Lemon · 8 pts
it's kinda hilarious that an absolute monarch was literally powerless against his own nobles. he had the crown but zero actual control over the guys blocking his tax reforms. absurd shit.
HarveyDentBeliever · 3 pts
Has anyone ever considered that this is *why* there was a revolution? It wasn't exactly staged by peasants alone, and they never got anything out of it. But the nobility sure did.
NokiaTube · Home