| VI | EN | RU | ID | Settings |
TIL that despite being blamed for the French Revolution, King Louis XVI actually tried to overhaul France's broken tax system by abolishing noble tax exemptions and passing a universal land tax—only to have his reforms repeatedly blocked by the aristocracy and courts.
r/todayilearned · u/PageVanDamme · 4.4K pts · 135 comments
britannica.com
135 comments
dovetc · 1.4K pts
His efforts did invite the revolution. He opened Pandora's box, but he and his forbearers had basically made that opening an inevitable fiscal necessity. Then having opened it, he botched the transition from absolute monarch to something more democratic by constantly wavering between paths. Let's not try to cast louis xvi as a reformer. He was a bungler and so were his ministers.
MasterpieceBrief4442 · 357 pts
France was so traumatized by the Mississippi Company Bubble that financial modernization came to be seen as anathema for a long time. So their tax collection was utterly bad.
Not only a patchwork quilt of exceptions but also contracting out to tax farmers and no real major banks on French soil. So when the budget and debt ballooned, they were forced to sell government posts, flog off even more future revenues to tax farmers and engage in desperate financial shenanigans.
Unlike Britain at this time which not only had numerous major banks but had streamlined its debt management through the So
PageVanDamme · -21 pts
Failure to reform doesn't mean he wasn't one tho.
Deltasims · 458 pts
"That's the thing Louis. You're an absolute monarch, so act like one. Tell the aristocracy to fuck off and implement your reforms"
This was unironically the sort of arguments you would hear from reformists in 1787-1789.
But Louis XVI was too weak and indecisive to do this so he instead called the Estates-General, and the rest is history
dovetc · 231 pts
Absolutism was seen as the progressive way in those times. Only an absolute monarch could dismantle the entrenched privileges of the nobility. Look at Poland in the 18th century - strong nobility resulting in a decentralized weak state.
Problem is, as you pointed out, you need a confident and competent leader to fill that role. Louis XVI was neither.
Otto_Von_Waffle · 54 pts
He genuinely could have sided with the revolutionary and sold himself as an enlightened monarch.
Learning about politics during those years is a sure way to start absolutely despising the nobility/landowner and actually mend things with royalty.
johnniewelker · 20 pts
Was the monarchy itself that strong to begin with? I think people over estimate how strong monarchs can be. Some societies had absolute strong monarchies. But most monarchies in Europe past 1600 were not as strong as people believe. You had to do a lot of politicking to stay in power.
It’s not unreasonable to think the Louis xvi thought that the nobility was the right stakeholder to ally with. After all they did wield a lot of power, just not enough
Just_Look_Around_You · 7 pts
To this day it’s the paradox of socialism. People friendly changes often require an iron fist against those very people to be made
Immediate_Gain_9480 · 1 pts
His grandfather wouldnt have hesitated for a second to do what was needed.
Crazy_Screwdriver · 1 pts
All he wanted was play with locks and clockworks :'(
oravanomic · 134 pts
Fun fact too, Napoleon's real talent was bureaucratic management.
Xabikur · 79 pts
It's funny that people think big military/political achievements are the result of an epic cavalry charge or an inspirational speech.
They're always the result of good project management.
fishanddipflip · 46 pts
His biggest legacy lives on in the institutions of all the countries he conquered
Low-HangingFruit · 1 pts
Sure until he tried that in Spain...
Crazy_Screwdriver · 1 pts
every laws were ready to be signed after the previous turmoil.
same thing happened to De Gaulle after he got elected in 65, 12 years of legislation was waiting to be signed.
Page 1 Next
NokiaTube · Home